Discover the Advantages of Having All Your Insurance Managed Under One Agency

We’re Real People

Established in 1983 in the family living room, The Feltner Group was founded based on the values of humanity and respect—core values that we still practice today with our clients in the Rochester, NY area. 

As a result, calling our office won’t get you stuck in an endless automated call loop with an AI bot. And you won’t receive quotes from a nameless email address. We value our relationships with our clients, and the way we do business proves it.

“The team at the Feltner Group is absolutely outstanding to work with. Their customer service is top notch and they make you feel like family.”
—Christina Sillick, verified Google review 



Our Connections Work for YOU

As independent insurance brokers with access to more than 25 carriers, we work for our clients – not for the insurance companies. That means we have the resources and connections to find the best policies to meet your needs. 

“In addition to his excellent customer service, Peter was able to find me a policy that fit my budget and provided the coverage I needed.” 
—Matt Camiolo, verified Google review 



We Shop for the Best Rates Possible—So You Don’t Have To

Whether it’s homeowners, car, or boat insurance; a business insurance or umbrella policy; or several of these all at once, it is our pleasure to “go shopping” for the best coverage at the lowest rates possible. No need to waste your time or go through the hassle of contacting the large insurance carriers yourself; we gather all the quotes for you.  

We can also reach out to more companies than you typically could or would on your own, and we know how to get the most competitive rates for the most comprehensive coverage.

“I finally feel like I have a partner with [Scott], who is looking out for MY company’s interests. He helped discover and resolve a $500k+ gap in coverage for my small business that our previous insurance broker had let slide for a decade.”
—Marlena Anchissi, verified Google review



Get a Free Consultation

How to Get the Best Quote Possible

  1. Have all necessary paperwork on hand before our initial consultation. This includes declaration pages from your existing polices and all the personal or business information available.
  2. Be as forthcoming as possible during our consultation. We can’t find the best coverage for you without knowing what you need coverage for. 
  3. Ask questions if you have them. What’s an umbrella insurance policy? Do you need one for your business? How much life insurance are you qualified for? All of these are valid and help us craft the perfect policy for you.
  4. Let us gather quotes. We’ll pick 3 or 4 companies that offer the best coverage for your situation, and then fine-tune the quotes and apply discounts wherever possible. From there, we identify the front-runner and present you with the best option available.

Get a Free Consultation

Stop managing multiple insurance policies without an expert to represent your needs.